On May 1, 2023, the WWE Superstar announced on Good Morning America that she was pregnant. "It's just all been such a whirlwind," she said. "I think because of my past, it was hard to get excited off the bat about this one, but I was cautiously optimistic. I try to have a good mindset, a positive mindset this time around, and it's working. So I'm very happy about that."

"I've been nauseous. I've been so tired, more tired than I've ever been in my life," she continued. "But I've never been so happy to feel so awful. I've been great, I mean mentally. It's kind of this weird space where I'm excited, but also just a little apprehensive because of the miscarriages. It's unfortunate that it robs you of the true excitement that should be there."

Carmella shared that she is due in November of 2023. Congratulations to the happy couple!