Our best guess up to the reveal was that iconic singer and Broadway star Jennifer Holliday was under the Miss Teddy mask, and this Reddit thread agreed. Jennifer has won two Grammy Awards, and the Santa clue could have been a play on words (holiday), in reference to her last name. Plus, all of those Dream Girls references!
Other Miss Teddy guesses include:
- Kathie Lee Gifford
- Hoda Kotb
- Wanda Sykes
- Martha Wash
- Rosie O'Donnell
- Melissa McCarthy