Jeremy reportedly met his ex-wife Sonni on the set of Mission Impossible: Ghost Protocol in 2011 and dated for three years before quietly tying the knot in January 2014. At the time, he confirmed his marriage to Capitol File magazine, explaining, "I have tried to protect my family’s privacy, my wife’s privacy. I don’t need her to get hammered with my life."

He added, "Privacy issues are important because I want her to go about her day without being bothered."

Sonni is a Canadian model, sculptor, realtor, and actress who has appeared as a background actor in a few films, such as American Pie Presents: The Book of Love and The Wingman. She had a small cameo in American Hustle, which also starred her then-husband Jeremy, and previously served as a spokesmodel for Monster Energy drinks. If you catch her on Instagram, you'll likely find her making art.

Unfortunately, Jeremy and Sonni's marriage was short-lived. The duo announced their divorce in December of 2014, per People magazine, where Sonni cited "irreconcilable differences" as the reason behind the divorce, also requesting their prenuptial agreement be voided because of "fraud." She also asked for physical custody of their daughter and child support.

In September 2019, however, their previously amicable split turned explosive when Sonni filed for sole legal and physical custody of their daughter and requested monitored visits, claiming Jeremy threatened to kill her and left drugs where Ava could reach them, according to court documents obtained by TMZ.

A statement by Jeremy's lawyer refuted Sonni's claims, saying, "The well-being of his daughter Ava has always been and continues to be the primary focus for Jeremy,” adding. “This is a matter for the court to decide. It’s important to note the dramatizations made in Sonni’s declaration are a one-sided account made with a specific goal in mind."