In a 41-minute YouTube video, James Charles basically annotates Tati's video, giving an explanation for everything she's accused him of. It's intense, but if you've been following the drama, it's worth the watch. In it, he explains that Ian Jeffrey actually wasn't tweeting about James. He was tweeting about a hometown bully, and Jeffree Star just assumed Ian was defending James.

James' brother apparently deleted his tweet sometime after Star attacked him, because no trace of this conversation can be found on Twitter. Yikes. The last tweet from Ian Jeffrey is one from May 10 that simply says "Shine bright in a world so dark."