During a February 2024 Access Hollywood interview, Jimmy said, "I want to congratulate Jess... she got an amazing edit."

He continued, "The simplest way for me to put it is that I had a three-and-a-half hour date with both of these ladies with no true decision at that point. Jess walks out in 10 minutes and was hammering me on not having a choice and not telling her I love her. If she loved me that much, shouldn't she have told me she loved me first? Shouldn't she have stayed there with me?"

In a separate interview with E! News, Jimmy called Jessica a "mean girl." She says on the reunion that she thought they were close, but after hearing what he said about her publicly, it might change things.

Either way, it seems Jimmy really had a problem with Jessica's tone and the fact that she wanted to push him to be accountable.