Jesse married his first wife, Noelle Inguagiato, in 2009. They first met on the job at the sets of Fox News. At the time, he worked on The O’Reilly’s Factor, whereas Noelle worked in the advertising and promotions department. She was also the host of the web show iMag Style.
In 2011, the couple welcomed a pair of twin daughters, Ellie Watters and Sophie Watters. However, the marriage lasted for almost a decade before Ellie Watters’ parents filed for divorce in October 2018. The pair separated because Jesse allegedly cheated on Noelle with his then-show producer, Emma DiGiovine.
Jesse Watters’ daughter shares a close bond with both her mother and father. Moreover, she and her twin sister must divide their time between the two loving homes.