At the reunion, Jessica said, "I saw an interview that you did recently, and I was infuriated... It seemed like you took the first opportunity you had to make an attempt at throwing me under the bus, but also flat-out bold-faced lie. You said I hammered you about wanting to explore your connections, which wasn't true. I said multiple times, when and if you choose me, if you do, I want you to be sure of it, so please explore and do whatever you need to do."

She finally asked, "What motivated you, like what provoked you and made you want to say horrible things about me?"

Jimmy justified his words saying that on his side of the story, he was being asked why he didn't choose Jessica, and brought up her leaving the date early as a justification. "You were literally saying 'what else do you freakin' need from me,'" he said. "And your tone of voice was just offsetting for me... and I didn't say horrible things about you."