Spencer James doesn't really exist. But he is based off of a real person. Like Spencer James, Spencer Paysinger grew up in South Central and played for a South Central high school football team. A coach from Beverly Hills saw him play and recruited him for his own team. And like All American's Spencer, he didn't want to go. 

Spencer told ESPN, "I did not want to go to Beverly Hills. I wanted to be with my closest friends. But my parents were not having it." Ultimately, his parents got the deciding vote and Spencer was sent to play for Beverly Hills. 

Spencer recalls that when he walked into Beverly Hills High School, it was "absolutely a culture shock." While it took some time for him to adjust, he eventually started to look at it as an opportunity and wanted to take advantage of it. But, back home, his transition to Beverly Hills was causing a strain on his friendships.

"In South Central, it definitely affected friendships," he said, but the strain wasn't only back home. Beverly Hills came with "their own set of stereotypes." 

Spencer credits football as being the reason he was able to adjust. Playing for the Beverly Hills team helped him "assimilate himself and build up friendships."

When asked about what he felt his story and All American are about, Spencer said, "it's about a kid diving into a whole new world, while still feeling an obligation to show respect to the world he comes from." 

After Spencer left Beverly Hills High School, he went to play for the Oregon Ducks at the University of Oregon. He then got drafted to play professional football as a linebacker for the New York Giants, Miami Dolphins, New York Jets, and Carolina Panthers until he retired in 2017.