Josh and Schuyler’s perceived arrangement to keep their relationship off social media seems to work for them. The couple hasn’t made any plans to get married yet, but they’re still going strong. After Josh’s past relationships with other women in the spotlight, he might prefer their privacy slightly more than his girlfriend.

Throughout his career, Josh has dated several A-listers, including Katy Perry, Mad Men actor January Jones, and Kat Dennings. Like his relationship with Schuyler, Josh kept those relationships as private as possible. However, he admitted in a February 2013 interview with Details magazine that he and January were “madly in love” during their two-and-a-half-year relationship.

After January, Katy and Josh dated and were quite fond of each other. According to HollywoodLife, Katy revealed in 2017 that her hit song “The One That Got Away” was about Josh. Who knew?! Apparently not Josh, who was equally shocked by Katy’s confession.

“We were both very private, so we realized we’re better as friends. We’ve been very good friends to this day; she’s the best,” Josh said in reaction to the reveal on Watch What Happens Live. “But I was not expecting that.”

He continued: “That was a double take and a spit of my coffee when I saw that. It’s very sweet of her to say that, and then I listened to the lyrics of the song, and I’m just like, ‘I never owned a Mustang. I don’t have a tattoo. Are you sure that’s about me?’ I’m very flattered by it, but I was very surprised by it too.”