The episode unfolded with a Naughty and Nice Challenge, where contestants scoured Santa's Lodge for clues to unveil Jill's kidnapper. Clues included gray hair around the bathrooms, reindeer mugshots of varying colors, different-colored reindeer collars, and hoof prints that potentially matched the reindeer mugshots.

Contestants made their guesses, Frankie emerged as the astute detective who correctly identified the culprit, showcasing his keen observation and deduction skills.