Kaya’s sudden departure from the show came shortly after another headline-making exit, made by contestant Sara Beth Liebe. In recent weeks, Sara has taken to social media to slam Katy for comments she made during the singer’s audition for the show.

The incident, which saw Katy quip about the 25-year-old’s three children. “Honey, you’ve been lying on the table too much,” Katy said upon initially learning of Sara’s age.

In the April 2 episode, Sara officially announced her exit from the show. “This opportunity is really rad, but this is actually gonna be my last performance because my heart’s at home,” Sara said after singing a rendition of “Roxanne.”

She further explained that being away from her family felt “selfish,” and that she didn’t think she could win the show anyway.

Katy then attempted to convince the Sara to stay, reminding her that she would be put through to the next round of the singing show. Despite the "I Kissed A Girl" singer's plea, Sara ultimately withdrew from the competition.

American Idol airs Sundays and Mondays at 8 pm EST on ABC.