It doesn't take a Hallmark movie to make a romantic love story come true! Italia is married to longtime boyfriend Robbie Amell, whom she started dating in 2008. The pair met on the set of American Pie: Beta House and often crossed paths on projects with one another, including Unnatural History. Both actors are Canadian, and they became engaged in August 2014, marrying two years later. 

Robbie is a well known actor in his own right, having starred in projects such as Cheaper By the Dozen 2, American Pie Presents: Beta House, The DUFF, True Jackson, VP, Scooby Doo! Curse of the Lake Monster, and more. He isn't the only actor in the family, as his cousin Stephen Amell is most well known for his portrayal of Oliver Queen on the hit television series Arrow. 

In 2019, the couple had their first child, son Robert Amell V. Italia's sweet Instagram caption said, "Today we welcome Robert Amell V into the world but also find out that being triple extra pregnant increases your odds of birthing Gollum." Italia has been posting truly adorable family pictures to her Instagram, typically with an exasperated parent caption.