In March 2021, a young woman who has remained anonymous to the public came forward to accuse D'Elia of violating child pornography laws and exploiting her as a minor. She alleged that, when she was 17 years old, she met D'Elia before one of his comedy shows and they engaged in sexual activity before he went on stage.

She also said that afterward, D'Elia continued to intimidate her into sending explicit images of herself over the internet, despite the fact that, according to her, D'Elia knew she was a minor. This comes off the heels of D'Elia's other allegations from women in 2011 and 2018, who both accused him of exposing himself to them in separate incidents when they were under the legal age of consent, despite his alleged knowledge of their ages.