In The Happiest Season, Aubrey plays an ex-girlfriend, Riley, to one of the main characters, Harper. In the movie, she bonds with Harper’s new girlfriend, Abby, who is at the helm of Harper's well-to-do family while Harper stays firmly in the closet. Abby and Riley engage in some major flirtations, to the point that fans are now calling for the movie to have an alternate ending where Riley and Abby end up together.

And Aubrey agrees. In a YouTube video with The Happiest Season co-star Daniel Levy, Aubrey spoke about the fan reception to her character’s would-be romance and she agreed that her character should have ended up with a happily ever after of her own instead of Harper. That could also just be Aubrey trolling everyone, but it only added to the questions of her sexuality in real life.