After Athena’s dad, Samuel, had a stroke and crashed into the family home, Athena and her husband travel to Florida to help out.

With their visit came a host of surprises. Upon her return home, Athena learned that the body of her childhood friend, Tanya Kingston, was buried underneath her home. As police searched for answers, all signs seemed to point to Samuel.

The Oct. 3 episode of 9-1-1 picked up where last week left off — with Athena in shambles. While she was hesitant to make assumptions about what really happened, the evidence against her father was glaring.

In an interview with Entertainment Weekly, Angela got candid about the Season 6 storyline. According to her, the possibility that her father could be involved somehow is “a scary thought” for Athena. She added, “And she doesn't want to even go there."

"The stranger doesn't look like the wolf or the devil. He looks, he's oftentimes someone very familiar to us,” the 9-1-1 actress told the outlet. “But the real monkey wrench in this is 'How well do you know your parents?'”

She continued, “You know your parents from a certain perspective through the eyes of just complete and utter love, respect, admiration. But then when there's suspicion, how is that shaken? Does that shake that love, that commitment? How far will you go? Will you hide bodies for them?"

Bobby, on the hand, is hard at work. While Athena pondered the plausibility of her father’s alleged crimes, her husband tries his hardest to crack the case. Peter told EW, “I don't think Bobby has any idea that Athena is concerned that there's a very, very real possibility that her father had something to do with this."

Athena’s father found himself at the center of controversy in Season 6, but this isn’t the first time he’s made a cameo on the show. So, who plays Samuel Carter on 9-1-1?