Shea made a brutal decision moments before the show's finale, the pinnacle of drama. He sent Taylor back to camp while he chose to stay in the villa!

Even the remaining contestants were shocked. This decision left a sour note on their budding romance, and things were not looking good for the future of their relationship.

Although Shea expressed remorse afterward, the impact on their relationship was undeniable. The couple faced scrutiny from both viewers and fellow contestants, and people were pretty certain that would seal their fate, and ruin any chance of a real relationship after the show.