The main clues that have fans asking questions involve Amy's clothing choices in recent Instagram posts. Most of her clothes are baggy in a way to allow her to hide a growing pregnant belly, if that's what she's doing. She also hasn't shared many recent photos where her body is shown from the chest down. And in a November 2023 Instagram post showing family photos with Dillon and Dax, it certainly seems like it could double as a pregnancy announcement shoot for a later date.

For now, Amy has not revealed a pregnancy in any capacity. So the speculation is just that — speculation and wonder among her fans and followers. Amy also owns a clothing boutique and some of her clothing options could very well be to drum up attention for that.

Not to mention that Amy has never been shy about sharing details of her life on social media. If she were pregnant, there's little chance of her not announcing it. Then again, maybe she's just waiting for the right time, if she is indeed expecting baby number two.