The 32-year-old has kept his new companion’s identity under wraps, but shared two photos of the couple’s intertwined legs via his Instagram stories. On one of the pics, he wrote, "Baby’s home."

90 Day Fiancé fans were hoping that the mystery woman was Kolini Faagata, the sister of fellow Season 6 star Kalani Faagata. The twosome previously engaged in a flirty social media exchange, but Kolini revealed on her own Instagram that she’s not the person in the photos. 

"Lol I don’t have a foot tattoo y’all, I’m sorry," the brunette beauty wrote, referring to the noticeable ink on top of the unidentified woman’s left foot. We’ll have to wait and see whether that tattoo keeps popping up on Jonathan’s page.